Home Values / Property Taxes / Pension … see how they have changed over the past two decades. Illinois Policy has an excellent analysis of where the money has gone.
Years ago, and unbeknownst to taxpayers, School district in Illinois began giving retiring teachers extra pay shortly before they retired. This policy costs the districts very little, but boosted pensions substantially. This practice is one of the leading causes of the unfunded pension liability.
The following table shows the post employment goodies for teachers in Wheaton-Warrenville CUSD 200.
“Comprehensive Annual Financial Report
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2015
Teachers’ Retirement System of the State of Illinois”
A teacher who had been retired less than one year (i.e. retired in 2015) who had 30 to 34 years of service on average would be receiving $5,661 in current monthly benefits, or $67,932 annually. Graphing the current monthly pensions from this page we get:
Notice the jump in the data about 20 years ago, That would be around 1995. Could this be due to end of career salary spiking?
Or was there any changes made tot he TRS law around this time that would account for the jump?
This report contains history, current law and funding levels for Illinois pension funds. A good reference document.
For instance page 82 of pdf has details for TRS, Tier 1 (hired prior to 1/1/2011)
- Basic Rate of Annuity: 2.2% per year of service
- Maximum Annuity: 75%
It would take just over 34 years to reach the max of 75%
Not listed here, unused sick and vacation days count towards service. Two years is not unusual.
If a teacher started right out of college at age 22, worked 33 years and cashed in 2 years of accrued sick/vacation days, that would allow him to retire at age 55 with FULL (75% of the average last 4 years of salary) benefits.
This report has data for each state run fund, each Chicago fund, and fire & police retirement funds for each municipality.
The Illinois Policy Institute has an excellent explanation of how teacher salaries increase over time. One way to reduce future pension costs is to stop giving large raises.
A previous version of this was posted on http://illinoisteaparty.net/pension-reform/.
An updated version is being posted here, on dupagewatchdogs.org now All links were valid when originally posted, but may no longer exist. http://archive.org/web/web.php A.K.A. way back machine may find the content of old links. Links for newer (updated data) are indicated in Blue.
The state funded public pension systems that are bankrupting the state of Illinois are “defined benefit” systems. Each system sets a level of employee contributions and promised benefits based upon a formula. The formulas assume matching employer (taxpayer) contributions, returns-on-investment, and amounts to be paid out based upon employee demographics, salary histories and actuarial tables. If everything had gone as planned, the pension funds would be fully funded; since it hasn’t, the taxpayers are expected to pick up the shortfall.
Consider the Teachers’ Retirement System (TRS) as an example. The following chart shows the ratio between the TRS assets and TRS obligations.
Notice that in 1987 the TRS was about 70% funded. In 1994, Illinois passed legislation increasing the amount the state would contribute to pension funds. In 2004, Illinois sold pension obligation bonds in hopes of shoring up the pension funds. The TRS assumed that the invested assets would earn 8.5% in return-on-investments. However actual returns-on-investment vary greatly. In 2001 and 2002 the TRS lost money, and from 2007 to 2009 the TRS lost about a fourth of its value. The 2013 Report lists a funding ratio based on “Actuarial value” of 40.6%
End of Career Salary Spiking
Another factor causing the pension shortfall was wide spread salary spiking which occurred during the last two decades. Salary spiking is defined as extra pay raises and/or high paying special projects that increase end of career salary and thus increase the pension for life. In 2010 salary spiking resulted in the TRS paying out $3 for every $2 it had anticipated paying. this chart is based on information from a 2011 FOIA request.
Pensions vs. Social Security and Incomes
Taxpayers never agreed to pay whatever it takes to fund public sector pensions, especially given the fact that many of these pensions exceed what those in the private sector receive.
- In 2014 the maximum Social Security for an individual retiring at age 66 was approximately $30,000.
- According to census.gov, (Table H-8B. Median Income of Households by State Using Three-Year Moving Averages: 1984 to 2012) Illinois’ three year median household income peaked in 1998 to 2000 period at $62,001 (inflation adjusted). It dropped to $52,284 in the 2010 to 2012 period. While many taxpayers saw their incomes decline, public sector pensioners received cost of living allowances (COLA). For instance, TRS paid a 3% compounded COLA.
- Based on data in the June 30, 2013 TRS “Comprehensive Annual Financial Report,” the average salary for those with less than 5 years experience was $46,058, for those with 30+ years, it was $97,715, overall average was $67,558 and the average starting pension for those retired less than a year after 30+ years of work was $70,894. Thus, an average recently retired teacher who worked a full career (30+ years) receives more in pension than the average active teacher earns for teaching, and more than the state’s median household income.
- Based on Taxpayers United of America (TUA), as of April 1, 2014 the top 200 Illinois public sector pensions ranged from $196,613 to $452,843. The majority are retired from universities followed by retired K-12 Superintendents. For instance, Dr. Catalani who retired from Wheaton-Warrenville CUSD 200 in 2007 now receives $284,674/year. His lifetime contributions cover 2.8% of his estimated lifetime benefits.
- As of April 1, 2014 there were 11,054 Illinois public sector pensioners collecting more than $100K per year and 78,526 pensioners collecting over $50K per year. (TUA).
The Illinois constitution requires our state government to have a balanced budget every year. It does allow for borrowing (for special purposes – or up to 15% of the annual budget for emergencies), yet, Illinois ended the fiscal year June 30, 2011, with over $8 billion in unpaid bills and an estimated $85 billion in unfunded pension liabilities. Combined ($8 + $85) was almost triple the 2011 budget which was around $33 billion.
In January 2011, Illinois “temporarily” raised its state income tax 67% and its corporate income tax 45% in an effort to stabilize its finances and to pay its $8.5 billion in past due bills. Despite generating about $30 billion in increased tax revenues (2011 to 2014) at the end of 2013 the state still had about $6.7 billion in past due bills and the unfunded liabilities have grown. The bulk of the new revenue from the increased tax rates went to state pension payments and Medicaid.
- In FY 1995 the state contributed $519 million to pensions which was 2.9% of the $17 billion general fund.
- In FY 2006 the state contributed $938 million to pensions which was 3.8% of the $24 billion general fund.
- In FY 2014 state contributions will be $5.99 billion, or 17% of the $35.7 billion general fund.
We are constantly being told that the under-funding problem is due to the state (taxpayers) not paying its fair share. However, according to actual past contributions and current projections, for the teachers’ retirement system:
- From 1995 to 2001 taxpayers contributed 93₵ for each $1.00 of member contribution,
- From 2002 to 2011 (last decade) taxpayers contributed $1.86 for each $1.00 of member contribution, and
- For 2012 to 2021 (current decade) taxpayers are projected to contribute $3.39 for each $1.00 of member contribution.
It appears that the state has always put in the “normal” portion, the part to cover benefits earned during the year, but, it has not always put in enough to cover the “actuarial” portion to make up for past shortfalls.
Illinois cannot balance the budget as required by law without addressing pensions. Legislation has already been passed to address employees hired after January 1, 2011, which will help a few decades from now. In order to solve the current problem, existing public sector employees and retirees must be part of the solution.
Minor pension reform did pass in 2013, but is being challenged in the courts. On a related item, the Court ruled in July 2014 that retiree healthcare could not be diminished due to Illinois’ Constitution Article XIII, Section 5:
“…Membership in any pension…shall be an enforceable contractual relationship, the benefits of which shall not be diminished or impaired.”
However, the court cannot force funding or timely payments. Already some hospitals and doctors are rationing care for state employees because they cannot afford to be the state’s bank. What good is insurance without access?
The Constitution is not a suicide pact. Given enough public pressure, it can be amended to change Article XIII, Section 5.
Links to source articles
- A law, IL – HB3813 to curb many of the pension abuses passed in December 2011 and was signed into law by Governor Quinn on January 5, 2012. http://www.wbez.org/story/pension-double-dipping-now-illegal-95335
- However, Madigan’s staff members proposed undoing it… http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/ct-met-pension-code-20111216,0,7785082.story
- Some people claim no pension already promised can ever be reduced because the Illinois constitution guarantees pensions. However, the Illinois Constitution also requires a balanced budget and the unfunded pension liabilities now exceed twice the annual budget.Illinois Constitution: Article XIII section 5 (pension) http://ilga.gov/commission/lrb/con13.htm
- Illinois Constitution: Article IX Section 9 (state debt) http://ilga.gov/commission/lrb/con9.htm
- The Illinois Constitution can be changed via the amendment process (legislature passes and citizens ratify). See Illinois Constitution: Article XIV http://ilga.gov/commission/lrb/con14.htm
- In 2010, IL enacted a two-tier pension system. Employees hired after 1/1/2011 will need to work longer, and will receive less or pay more. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/25/illinois-pension-reform-l_n_513174.html
- Illinois supreme Court ruling on diminishing retiree health care http://online.wsj.com/articles/illinois-tax-mandamus-1404863390
Pension Statistics, Shortfall & Abuse:
- The gap between how much the state retirement plans have and how much retirees have earned, as of last fiscal year was $85.6 billion . The pension deficit five years ago was $38.6 billion. It is ballooning. http://dailyherald.com/article/20111106/news/711069888/
- In 2012 the state is supposed to come up with $6.9 billion for pensions. That is 21% more than the $5.7 billion it contributed in 2011. http://www.nbcchicago.com/blogs/ward-room/Whats-on-Tap-for-Illinois-in-2012-136537428.html
- FY 1995 General Fund $17,302 pension $519 which is 2.9%
FY 2006 General Fund $24,406 pension $938.4 which is 3.8%
(figure 11 in “Citizen’s Guide to the Illinois Budget and Tax System” (2008))
- FY 2014 state contributions will be $5.99 billion, or 17% of the $35.7 billion general fund http://www.ctbaonline.org/sites/default/files/reports/ctbaonline.org/node/add/repository-report/1389805096/R_2013.10.1_FY2014_Updated%20Enacted%20Illinois%20General%20Fund%20Budget%20Analysis.pdf
- IL’s State University Retirement System (SURS) funding ratio dropped from 88% in 2000 to just 45% at the end of the last fiscal year [June 30, 2011].
- Workers who retired between July 1, 2009 and June 30, 2010 after 30 or more years on the job could expect initial average annual benefit payments of:$68,208 in the State Universities Retirement System;$65,109 in the Teachers’ Retirement System; or$38,916 in the State Employees’ Retirement System. http://www.illinoispolicy.org/news/article.asp?ArticleSource=4523&utm_source=Illinois+Policy+Institute&utm_campaign=39279f44cc-Nov+17%2C+2011+E-letter&utm_medium=email (link no longer exist)
- On average, teachers retire age at 58, after working 25 years, with a starting TRS pension of $46,000… compared to social security… http://www.championnews.net/2011/06/14/4882/
- Service towards pension can be purchased for work done in other states. For example, one retiree purchased 12 years of service for $29,338.27 and boosted his starting pension by $75,000/yr http://www.championnews.net/2010/07/14/retiree-gets-224000-pension-for-18-years-worked/
- Union leaders receive TRS pensions based on their union salaries for substitute teaching one day. http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/ct-met-pensions-teacher-perk-20111023,0,7187206.story
- 3,062 employees out-earn the governor on base salary. Their total compensation exceeds $1 billion. The job categories most represented are local school administrators, county and village managers (500), judges (600), college/university professors (1350) and government doctors (600). http://forthegoodofillinois.org/blog/2011/09/illinois-billionaire-bureaucrat-club-q-a (link no longer available)
- As of April 1, 2011 there were 5,294 government retirees receiving pensions of at least $100,000 per year and the top 100 pensions range from $195,000 to $414,471. http://www.taxpayersunitedofamerica.org/wp-content/uploads/Top100April2011.pdf
- As of April 1, 2014 there were 11,054 pensioners collecting more than $100K per year; 78,526 pensioners collecting over $50K per year; and the top 200 pensions range from $196,613 to $452,843. This also lists the top 200 state pension recipients, http://www.taxpayersunitedofamerica.org/wp-content/uploads/Top200Grids-2014.pdf
- The average starting salary of a college graduate six years ago was $48,000 per year. Now it is $24,000 for those who can find a job at all. http://www.ice-news.net/2014/07/12/the-obamaconomy/?utm_source=ICE+News+List&utm_campaign=0adf5f635f-396&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_dd95a12ff2-0adf5f635f-310520489#sthash.1Kf6JmXs.dpuf
- Census.gov, Table H-8B. Median Income of Households by State Using Three-Year Moving Averages: 1984 to 2012 http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/income/data/historical/household/2012/H08B_2012.xls
- Anatomy of a Teacher’s Contract: Blueprint for a Taxpayer Mugging
- TRS History http://trs.illinois.gov/subsections/general/history.pdf
- Chicago Public schools pay millions for accumulated sick days, which may be accumulated over the career and are cashed in based on the final salary rate. Furthermore, they count towards the pension (spiking). http://www.suntimes.com/10389568-417/cps-spends-millions-on-workers-for-unused-sick-and-vacation-days.html
- Illinois Considers Further Income Tax Increases as Temporary Tax Nears Expiration http://taxfoundation.org/article/illinois-considers-further-income-tax-increases-temporary-tax-nears-expiration
Raw Data is Available
- For the Good of Illinois has posted IL public sector salary and pension data… http://www.openthebooks.com/
- Family Taxpayer Foundation has teacher data which is downloadable by district… http://www.familytaxpayers.org/
- TRS validation report 2011 http://trs.illinois.gov/subsections/general/Buck_2011_valuation_rept.pdf Schedules XIV and XV have details for contribution portion
- TRS Validation report 2013 http://trs.illinois.gov/pubs/actuarial/2013valuationrept.pdf
- TRS validation report 2008 http://web.archive.org/web/20101027070314/http://trs.illinois.gov/subsections/pubs/cafr/fy09/actuarial.pdf
- 2013 TRS “Comprehensive Annual Financial Report,” http://trs.illinois.gov/pubs/cafr/FY2013/fy13.pdf
- 2014 TRS “Comprehensive Annual Financial Report,” http://trs.illinois.gov/pubs/cafr/FY2014/fy14.pdf
- 2015 TRS “Comprehensive Annual Financial Report,” http://trs.illinois.gov/pubs/cafr/FY2015/fy15.pdf (salary on pdf page 100 & 101 overall average is now $69,538, pensions on pdf page 109 – Average original benefit for those retired less than 1 year and 30-34 years of experience = $5,646 monthly which is $67,752 annually) Looks like salary has continued upward while starting pension has come down slightly.
- Pensions vs. schools by the Illinois Policy Institute http://illinoispolicy.org/news/article.asp?ArticleSource=4597&utm_source=Illinois+Policy+Institute&utm_campaign=7d6454a527-Nov+22%2C+2011+E-letter&utm_medium=email
- Champion News has an extensive list of pension articles: http://www.championnews.net/category/pension-crisis/
- 1/30/2012, (CHICAGO) The Civic Federation’s Illinois research institute warns that Illinois could face an unprecedented $34.8 billion backlog of unpaid bills [by FY2017] if action is not taken immediately to reform Pensions and Medicaid. http://www.civicfed.org/FY2013IllinoisRoadMapPressRelease
Illinois actually has many public sector pension funds. The following table summarizes the five large state wide pension funds that are in trouble financially.
- TRS – Teachers’ Retirement System
- SERS – State Employees’ Retirement System
- SURS – State Universities Retirement System
- JRS – Judges’ Retirement System
- GARS – General Assembly Retirement System
Updated – Five largest pension funds in 2014
http://www.examiner.com/independent-in-chicago/secret-memo-shows-no-confidence-illinois-state-pensions#ixzz1rGhddiAp February 9 memo from Executive Director, Dick Ingram, to the Teachers Retirement System Board of Directors warns that the State will be forced to not only cut from future pension funds, but also from currently retired teachers’ pensions.
Today [May 8, 2012], the combined unfunded liabilities of Chicago’s four pension funds have grown to nearly $20 billion, which doesn’t include the $6.8 billion shortfall at the teachers fund.
Absent reforms, the fund for retired city firefighters would become insolvent in nine years, according to a city report issued two years ago. The police pension would go broke four years later. All four funds would be broke by 2030.